The Costs of Winning …. at All Costs
![]()
One of the biggest challenges that we face in youth sports is the emphasis on winning but it is no wonder when youth sports coaches and players see the example being set by professional sports.
Sadly though, when youth sports focus on winning vs. the process of development it has lead to the high attrition rates that we are seeing today with kids quitting a game they once loved and played for the Love of the Game.
The same holds true in professional sports where the infamous asterisk has been used to identify records or titles that were clouded with scandals of cheating to get the competitive advantage to win at all costs.
The most recent example is the MLB investigation that was announced just a few hours before the NCAA National Championship game that the Houston Astros had cheated stealing signs to give them a competitive advantage which lead to them winning the World Series.
It was not the fact that they stole the signs for pitchers, it was the fact that they incorporated such an elaborate scheme to do so using technology that has been forbidden since the beginning of time in professional sports.
This is not the first, not do I suspect it will be the last instance where cheating was incorporated by individual athletes, teams or organizations to win.
These are the top 10 scandals of cheating in professional sports starting with the most recent.
#1 – Varsity Blues 2019
Over $25 Million in bribes to various NCAA Div 1 schools from parents to officials including coaches paid by William Rick Singer to inflate SAT scores or ensure their sons or daughters would receive a spot on an NCAA collegiate sports team in 11 different universities.
The bribes accepted by coaches ranged from $100,000 (Michael Carter, U of T Tennis Coach), $400K (Rudy Meredith – Yale Head Soccer Coach), $1.3 M USC’s Senior AD.
The investigation also includes Lori Loughlin (Full House Sitcom) and Felicity Huffman who had issued bribes and plead guilty and were sentenced to jail time.
This was definitely a hit to the integrity of the Ivy League School’s academic and athletic programs.

#2 – 2017-18 NCAA DIV I Men’s Basketball corruption scandal
On Sept 27, 2017 the FBI and USA attorney announced the arrest of 10 individuals on various charges of corruption, money laundering, fraud and bribery that also involved Adidas.
A few months later that the FBI had hundreds of pages of documents that named over a dozen schools, including NCAA National Champion North Carolina, and 25 athletes that were involved in the scandal.
Many of those accused in the scandal were arrested and are waiting for their time in court to prove their innocence (or NOT).

#3 – The Most Recent to come to light after 2-year investigation; The Houston Astros Stealing Signs 2017 World Series Winning Season
Incorporating technology so they could steal signs made by the catcher so batters could get a competitive advantage if they would see a fastball or an off-speed pitch.
The scheme was so elaborate that ALL players on the team knew (but none were suspended) and whenever they were up to bat and either the screen or tablet used in their dugout showed that the catcher called an offspeed pitch one of their players would hit the garbage can. It gave them such a home-field advantage in the ALCS against the Yankees they won 2-1, 2-1 at home then lost 8-1, 6-4 and 5-0 in New York, then won 7-1 and 4-0 when returned back to home.
What … no one clued into the garbage can being hit in the ALCS ONLY when Houston was at Home? The World Series Only when they were at home when the MLB is infamous for analytics ?
What amazed me when I saw the announcement come to light was the fact that it took OVER 2 years for the MLB to complete their investigation that they Astros had in fact done so and many are arguing that the penalties being enforced by MLB commissioner are not harsh enough
$5 Million Fine – Suspensions to both the manager (AJ Hinch) and General Manager (Jeff Luhnow) as well as the loss of first and second draft picks for the 2020 and 2021 season.
The team owner, Jim Crane, issued a statement that both were fired soon after the announcement made by the MLB.
There is also a further investigation into whether Alex Cora, bench boss in 2017 who became the Boston Red Sox manager and lead them to the world series in 2018 continued to use the same cheating scheme so he too may be suspended.

# 4 – Deflategate 2014 – New England Patriots
Although the Patriots will not play in the Superbowl this season as they were knocked out by Bill Belichek Protégé Mike Vrabel’s Tennessee Titans, they have been one of the most dominating organizations in the past 2 decades, winning 6 super bowls with Tom Brady.
There first of two asterisks on what should be an amazing run and legacy where Tom asked for the game balls provided to the Colts be deflated used in the AFC championship game vs. the Colts in 2014 that the Patriots won and subsequently won to advance to the Superbowl and defeated the Seahawks
As a result of allegations Tom was suspended for 4 games to start the following season, the Patriots received a $1 Million Fine and lost two draft picks.
Was it worth it Tom?

# 5 – Bountygate – New Orleans Saints 2009
Although I am a HUGE fan of Drew Brees and everything he has accomplished in his amazing career, since he lead the Saints to their Superbowl victory in 2009 it was with a sour taste in my mouth.
The Reason?
That his long-term head coach, Sean Payton, was accused of paying out bonuses to players from 2009 (the year they won the Superbowl) until 2011 for players who injured players on opposing teams.
After an investigation into allegations from other teams, the NFL brought down the most severe sanctions they had in their then 87-year history, Saints Defensive Coordinator was suspended indefinitely, Sean Payton was suspended the entire 2012 season, General Manager was suspended 8 games and assistant coach 6 games. The organization was fined $500,000 and lost their second-round draft picks in 2012 and 2013.

#6 – Spy Gate 2007: New England Patriots
Bill Belichek et al was disciplined by the league for using technology to videotape New York Jets Defensive Coordinators signals from an unauthorized location. Bill received a $500,000 fine (maximum allowable at the time), the Team a $250,000 fine and they lost their first-round draft pick.
What Bill, you could not beat one of the worst franchises of all time in the NFL without breaching NFL rules WHERE you could videotape?

#7 – Marion Lois Jones – Steroid Use
Marion was a former Olympic champion track and field athlete for the USA and won three gold and two bronze medals representing the USA in the 2000 Summer Olympics who of one of the most famous athletes linked to the BALCO scandal for steroid use, that included over 20 top-level athletes.
She was stripped of all of her Olympic and subsequent IAAP World Championship medals when she owned up to the fact that she originally had used steroids, after the initially denied doing so in the BALCO investigation.
In 2007 as a result of losing sponsorships, unable to compete in track she ran into financial troubles and declared bankruptcy. The bank foreclosed on her $2.5 Million mansion and was forced to sell other properties including one she purchased for her mother.
In 2008 she was sentenced to 6 months imprisonment for check fraud and use of performance-enhancing drugs.
A decade later I had the opportunity to see her speak at a conference I was also speaking at and she shared her remorse how the pressure to win forced her to do everything possible to do so, but as a result, she lost everything and had to start over.

#8 – MLB Steroid Scandal 1990’s
Asterisks note that the home runs made by Sammy Sosa, Mark McGuire, Barry Bonds, and Alex Rodriguez among others was a result of taking performance-enhancing steroids banned by the MLB and all other professional sports. I suspect if Babe Ruth was alive today he would be spitting chewing tobacco at all of them for doing so.
Sadly, I had the opportunity to witness a home run made by Sammy at Wrigley Field before the scandal was brought forward where he hit it onto the roofs of the fans houses who watched from each home game and then a year later the Steroid Scandal came to light so it is not a highlight, more a sour note for me.

#9 – Lance Armstrong – Cycling Doping Scandal 1999-2005
Yet another example of what all felt was such an amazing accomplishment at the time was Lance Armstrongs 7 consecutive Tour De France Titles (from 1999-2005) and what made it more amazing is he had battled and successfully fought testicular cancer before his amazing run.
What many felt was the reason he was able to accomplish what he did was his amazingly high VO2 Max of 83.8 ml/kg/min which was almost twice that of the average person which gave him a natural competitive advantage in those long rides thru the French Alps.
In 2004 the first allegations came forward that Armstong and other team riders were using performance-enhancing drugs which started a series of investigations for the next decade with countersuits filed by Armstrong arguing slander and defamation of character.
As a result of the allegations being brought forth found accurate, Lance was stripped of his 7 Tour De France Titles, lucrative sponsorship deals and also had lawsuits filed against him by former teammates, sponsors.
A perfect example if it is too good to be true, it is.
How long has corruption, cheating been a means for players or organizations to win at all costs in professional sports ?
Over 100 Years !!!

#10 – 1919 World Series Chicago White Sox (AKA Eight Men Out)
The original scandal impacting the MLB where 8 members of the 1919 Chicago White Sox were accused of throwing the series vs. the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for money from a gambling syndicate.
What was ironic at the time was the Philadelphia Bulletin published a poem during that world series that was very appropriate at the time and still is:
Still, it really doesn’t matter,
After all, who wins the flag.
Good clean sport is what we’re after,
And we aim to make our brag
To each near or distant nation
Whereon shines the sporting sun
That of all our games gymnastic
Baseball is the cleanest one!
_ Unknown
What all the examples above show is the costs of winning at ALL costs can include financial ruins, loss of sponsorships or scholarships, contracts, credibility, fame, criminal prosecution and the worst thing of all …..
Loss of integrity.
Is winning at all costs really worth it?
Nope.
Take the high road always.










